10 Common Open Enrollment Mistakes Brokers Can Prevent

Blog

Yellow road sign reading Open Enrollment Ahead beside a winding forest road

Learn the 10 most common open enrollment mistakes brokers should watch for, with practical ways to prevent enrollment errors, reduce employee confusion, and keep clients on track.

Table of Contents

  1. Open enrollment moves fast, and small mistakes can add up
  2. Confirm deadlines and responsibilities early
  3. Verify plan details before communicating changes
  4. Help employees compare more than premiums
  5. Keep employee benefits communication simple
  6. Pay close attention to provider networks and prescription coverage
  7. Test the enrollment platform before employees begin
  8. Follow up on incomplete enrollments
  9. Establish a clear process for handling employee questions
  10. Coordinate enrollment documents and notices early
  11. Follow through after enrollment closes
  12. Key Takeaways

Open enrollment moves fast, and small mistakes can add up

Open enrollment brings a steady stream of deadlines, client questions, enrollment changes, and details that need immediate attention. One employer may still be finalizing contributions while another needs help resolving an enrollment issue, and HR teams are counting on brokers to keep everything moving.

Even with careful preparation, a few details can slip through when several tasks need attention at once. A deadline may be misunderstood, an employee guide may contain outdated information, or an enrollment issue may take longer to resolve because the right contact wasn’t identified.

Many of these situations are familiar to experienced brokers, and a few extra checks at the right time can help prevent them from becoming larger problems.

Here are 10 common open enrollment issues worth watching for, along with practical ways to keep the process organized, support your clients, and help employees make informed decisions.

Confirm deadlines and responsibilities early

Open enrollment involves several timelines that don’t always match. Carriers have submission deadlines, employers need time to approve materials, payroll teams must prepare deductions, and enrollment platforms have their own configuration schedules.

When one task falls behind, it can affect several others. For example, a delay in approving employee contributions may hold up enrollment materials or platform updates.

A shared enrollment timeline can help everyone stay aligned. Include carrier deadlines, employer approval dates, platform testing, employee communications, and enrollment submission requirements.

It’s also useful to identify who is responsible for each step. When a carrier needs additional information or HR has a last-minute question, everyone should know who can provide an answer.

Helpful tip: Prioritize deadlines that cannot be extended and confirm any outstanding approvals early. A quick status check with your client can prevent unnecessary follow-up when enrollment activity increases.

Hand pointing to a document on a clipboard beside a laptop on a wooden desk

Verify plan details before communicating changes

Plan information sometimes changes between the initial proposal and the final enrollment materials. Rates may be adjusted, employer contributions may be updated, or a plan design may be revised before enrollment begins.

If employee materials are prepared using earlier information, HR may receive questions about why the benefit guide shows one amount while the enrollment platform shows another.

Before distributing materials, confirm that the information matches the finalized plan documents. Pay particular attention to premiums, deductibles, copays, out-of-pocket maximums, employer contributions, and coverage details.

Keeping one approved version of the information also helps prevent different teams from working with outdated documents.

A simple final review involving the broker, employer, and appropriate administrator can identify inconsistencies before employees begin making their elections.

Help employees compare more than premiums

Premiums naturally receive a lot of attention during open enrollment because employees can immediately see how much will come out of their paychecks.

According to KFF’s 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey, workers with family coverage contributed an average of $7,471 annually toward their health insurance premiums, a 9% increase from 2025.¹

With employee contributions representing a meaningful expense, it’s understandable that many people focus on finding a plan with an affordable premium.

However, premiums tell only part of the cost story.

An employee who regularly visits specialists or takes prescription medications may have different financial priorities than someone who rarely uses medical services. Deductibles, copays, coinsurance, prescription costs, and out-of-pocket maximums can all influence which plan is a better fit.

Brokers can help employers present these differences in a way employees can easily understand.

Consider recommending a side-by-side comparison that includes payroll deductions, common medical expenses, prescription coverage, and potential out-of-pocket costs. A few examples of how each plan handles common services can make the differences easier to understand.

The goal is to give employees enough information to evaluate their options based on how they expect to use their coverage.

Broker taking notes while meeting with a client at a table with a laptop

Keep employee benefits communication simple

Employees receive a significant amount of information during open enrollment, including benefit guides, plan comparisons, carrier documents, enrollment instructions, and reminders.

Even when those materials contain everything employees need, finding a specific answer can take time.

A MetLife survey found that only 57% of employees fully understood what their benefits covered. Separately, 72% said they wanted benefits communications tailored to their needs.²

These findings point to a useful opportunity for brokers to help employers make benefit information easier to understand and use.

Start with the questions employees are most likely to ask:

  • What is changing from my current plan?
  • How much will my coverage cost?
  • What do I need to do to enroll?
  • When is the deadline?
  • Who can help if I have questions?

A short FAQ addressing these topics can be a useful addition to the required plan documents. It can also help HR provide consistent answers without repeatedly searching through longer materials.

When explaining plan changes, focus on what employees need to know to make their elections. Use familiar terms where possible, and explain insurance terminology when it affects coverage or costs.

Paying close attention to provider networks and prescription coverage

Provider networks and prescription benefits deserve a closer look when employees are choosing coverage, especially when an employer is changing carriers or offering different plan options.

An employee may assume their current doctor participates in a new plan because the same insurance company is involved. However, carriers can offer multiple networks, and participation may vary by specific plan.

Prescription coverage can create similar questions. A medication covered under one plan may have a different copay, formulary tier, or authorization requirement under another. Some specialty medications may also require employees to use a designated pharmacy.

These details are particularly relevant because employees may not always know which benefits or coverage resources are available to them.

Brokers can help employers encourage employees to verify a few important details before making their elections, including whether their preferred providers and facilities participate in the plan, whether their medications are covered, and whether any pharmacy restrictions or prior authorization requirements apply.

It’s also helpful to direct employees to the carrier, pharmacy benefit manager (PBM), or plan administrator for confirmation of current coverage information.

Test the enrollment platform before employees begin

Enrollment platforms make it easier to manage elections, but the information employees see still depends on how the system has been configured.

Contribution amounts, eligibility rules, plan options, and dependent information all need to match the employer’s approved benefits.

A platform may allow employees to log in successfully while still displaying incorrect rates or enrollment options. These issues can be harder to address once employees have started submitting elections.

Before enrollment opens, coordinate with HR and the enrollment platform administrator to test the process from an employee’s perspective.

Review how the system handles plan selection, dependent additions, coverage waivers, payroll deductions, and confirmation screens. Testing different employee scenarios can help identify settings that need attention.

For example, the process may work correctly for an employee selecting individual coverage but display an incorrect contribution when that employee adds a dependent.

Testing the full enrollment experience can help catch these issues before they affect actual elections.

Follow-up on incomplete enrollments

Sending an open enrollment announcement is a good starting point, but employees may still miss a deadline, overlook a required action, or begin an election without completing it.

Some may also assume their current coverage will automatically continue, even when the employer requires an active election.

Brokers can help HR monitor participation throughout the enrollment period and identify employees who may need additional reminders.

When possible, review enrollment reports that distinguish employees who have completed their elections from those who have not started or are still in progress. It’s also important to confirm how the platform records employees who actively waive coverage.

Rather than sending the same reminder to everyone, employers can focus follow-up messages on employees who still need to take action.

A useful reminder should clearly explain what remains incomplete, when the deadline is, and how the employee can finish the process.

As enrollment closes, checking outstanding elections against employer and carrier requirements can help reduce last-minute complications.

Single black line forming a tangled knot that straightens out and ends in a light bulb

Establish a clear process for handling employee questions

During open enrollment, questions can come from several directions. HR may need clarification about eligibility, an employee may have trouble accessing the platform, or someone may need help understanding prescription coverage.

Not every question requires the same response or the same person to resolve it.

An enrollment access issue may belong with the platform administrator, while a provider network question may require confirmation from the carrier. Prescription coverage questions may need involvement from the PBM or another pharmacy benefits resource.

Without a clear process, questions may be forwarded between multiple contacts before reaching someone who can help.

Brokers can work with employers to establish a simple escalation process that identifies where different types of questions should go and who is responsible for following up.

It can also help to distinguish time-sensitive enrollment issues from general benefits questions. An employee who cannot submit an election before the deadline may need a faster response than someone requesting general plan information.

Keeping a shared record of unresolved issues, assigned contacts, and next steps can help ensure that questions receive follow-up without creating additional work for everyone involved.

Leaving important enrollment documents and notices until the last minute

Enrollment materials involve more than benefit guides and employee presentations.

Depending on the plan and employer, required documents may include Summary of Benefits and Coverage (SBC) materials, applicable notices, eligibility information, and other enrollment disclosures.

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) explains that SBCs must be provided at certain points in the enrollment process, including enrollment and renewal. Specific responsibilities and timing depend on the plan and enrollment circumstances.³

Because these materials may involve employers, carriers, administrators, and other parties, it’s worth confirming who is responsible for preparing and distributing each document.

A documentation checklist can help organize the process. Include the required materials, responsible party, distribution method, applicable deadline, and confirmation that the task has been completed.

This also gives brokers a clear way to follow up when documents are still pending without assuming another party has already handled them.

Follow through after enrollment closes

When the enrollment deadline passes and employees have submitted their elections, the busiest part of the process may be over. However, a few important steps remain before coverage begins.

Enrollment files still need to be received and processed, eligibility information must match the employer’s records, and payroll deductions need to reflect the elections employees made.

For example, an employee may have added a dependent during enrollment, but that change may not appear correctly in the carrier’s records. Another employee may have selected a different plan while payroll still reflects the previous contribution amount.

A post-enrollment reconciliation process can help identify these differences before they create coverage or payroll questions.

Work with the employer and appropriate administrators to confirm that enrollment files were received and processed, review discrepancies, and verify effective dates and dependent information.

It’s also helpful to make sure HR knows where employees should go for questions about ID cards, coverage, claims, or other benefits issues once the new coverage period begins.

Keep your clients supported through open enrollment

Enrollment questions don’t always end when elections close. Trinity helps brokers and employers provide ongoing benefits guidance and member support.

Learn More About Trinity

Key Takeaways

  • Confirm deadlines and responsibilities early: Keep everyone aligned on approvals, submissions, and outstanding tasks.
  • Verify plan information before sharing it: Make sure enrollment materials, contribution amounts, and platform settings match the approved benefits.
  • Make coverage decisions easier for employees: Explain total potential costs, provider networks, prescription coverage, and required enrollment actions.
  • Keep communication and follow-up organized: Use clear instructions, targeted reminders, and defined contacts for employee questions.
  • Check enrollment records after elections close: Confirm that coverage information has been processed correctly and outstanding discrepancies have been addressed.

Footnote Markers:

¹ https://www.kff.org/health-costs/2025-employer-health-benefits-survey/

² https://www.metlife.com/about-us/newsroom/2025/september/new-metlife-data-finds-half-of-employees-report-feeling-disconnected-undervalued-at-work/

³ https://www.cms.gov/cciio/resources/fact-sheets-and-faqs/indexsummarybenefitscoverage